Indian Gambling Officials Urge Regulation by Compacts - Sunday 14th of May 2006
by Tony Batt
Las Vegas Gaming Wire
WASHINGTON, D.C Indian gambling officials on Thursday told a House panel that tribal casino regulations should be controlled by agreements between tribes and states, not the federal government.
Last month, the Senate Indian Affairs Committee passed a bill by Sen. John McCain, R-Ariz., that would authorize a federal agency the National Indian Gaming Commission to regulate tribal casinos.
Rep. Richard Pombo, R-Calif., chairman of the House Resources Committee, is working on his own Indian gaming bill but has not decided whether to expand federal regulation.
McCain's bill would override a federal judge's ruling in August 2005, saying the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act of 1988 does not empower the National Indian Gaming Commission to regulate tribal casinos.
Phil Hogen, chairman of the National Indian Gaming Commission, said the 1988 law needs to be clarified so the commission can do its job.
"We are finding the door slammed in our face," Hogen told the House Resources Committee. "We sent two of our investigators ... out to Western Montana this week and when they got there, they were denied access (to an Indian casino), and the tribe pointed to the ruling ... to keep us out."
But Franklin Ducheneaux, a member of the Minnesota Indian Gaming Association and a former counsel to the late Rep. Morris Udall, D-Ariz., who helped craft the 1988 law, said Congress did not intend to authorize federal regulation of tribal casinos.
The law limited federal regulation to bingo and other tribal operations less sophisticated than casinos to preserve tribal sovereignty, Ducheneaux said.
When the National Indian Gaming Commission began imposing minimum auditing and internal control standards on tribal casinos in 1999, Indian gaming officials argued this was a violation of the 1988 law.
The friction led to last year's ruling in favor of the Colorado River Indian Tribes of Arizona which challenged the National Indian Gaming Commission's minimum internal control standards for its casino.
"If Congress believes it is necessary for the (Indian Gaming Regulatory Act) to address the (minimum internal control standards), it should do so in a way that is deferential to the regulatory scheme negotiated between tribes and states in their compacts,' said Raymond Aspa, a member of the tribal council of the Colorado Indian River Tribes.
Ernie Stevens Jr., chairman of the National Indian Gaming Association, said tribes spent $320 million last year on regulation and employ more than 2,800 regulators.
Norman DesRosiers, a commissioner for the Viejas Tribal Gaming Commission in Alpine, Calif., said tribes that comply with minimum internal control standards for three years should be eligible for a certificate of "self-regulation."
Kevin Washburn, a law professor at the University of Minnesota, said state regulation of Indian gambling has been "spotty," and the industry has become so important to tribes that it must be protected.
"That's largely why I think the federal government should have this (regulatory) role," Washburn said.
Other news from around the same time
Mergers and Acquisitions: Hard Rock Sold for $770 Million - Sunday 14th of May 2006
by Hubble SmithLas Vegas Gaming WireThe Hard Rock Hotel, a pop icon in Las Vegas with its signature....
Isle Plans Expansion in Florida Market - Sunday 14th of May 2006
FLORIDA As reported by the QC Times: "Isle of Capri Casinos will expand its gaming offerings in so....
Blind Curve Casino Bus in Collision - Sunday 14th of May 2006
BLACK HAWK, Colorado As reported by the Rocky Mountain News: "A casino bus hit a utility truck hea....
Biloxi Mayor Says Casinos Will Again Revitalize Region - Sunday 14th of May 2006
by Howard StutzLas Vegas Gaming WireBILOXI, Mississippi Mayor A.J. Holloway watched during his fir....
Gavin Smith Named World Poker Tour Player of the Year - Saturday 13th of May 2006
Los Angeles, CA (Press Release) Professional poker player Gavin Smith capped his strong year of p....
Thai Authorities Warn Against Holiday Gambling - Saturday 13th of May 2006
CHIANG RAI, Thailand – As reported by the TNA News: "Thai police in the northern border town of M....
Casino Rumors Surround Trump Philadelphia Tower - Saturday 13th of May 2006
PENNSYLVANIA – As reported by the Commercial Property News: "Donald Trump has unveiled plans to b....
Meadows Plans $450 Million Expansion - Saturday 13th of May 2006
PITTSBURGH, Pennsylvania – As reported by the Pittsburgh Post-Tribune: "Daily attendance at The M....
Former Indonesian President Suggests Casino - Saturday 13th of May 2006
INDONESIA – As reported by the Jakarta Post: "Former president Habibie has suggested the governme....
Hundreds Expected for East Coast Gaming Congress - Saturday 13th of May 2006
ATLANTIC CITY, New Jersey – Hundreds of casinoexecutives, slot manufacturers, analysts, regulat....